Tuesday, September 11, 2012

THE DANGER OF LIVING IN THE "PERPETUAL UTTERANCE OF SELF-APPLAUSE"

The popular song of the WW I era, "How will you keep 'em down on the farm (after they've seen Paree)?" (by Lewis, Young and Donaldson, 1918) underscored the troubling question about the perceptions of returning doughboys and how they might change once they were exposed to the wider more sophisticated world in Europe. Perhaps Lewis and Young who wrote the lyrics were aware of our isolation, and insularism, and saw it as a potential problem as far back as the outbreak of WWI, nearly a hundred years ago. Today, that problem has not ameliorated much, even with all our scintillating technology, i-pads, i-pods and i-phones, pulsing internet, a decade of deploying hundreds of thousands of troops to the Middle East,(and still little change in interest in the languages and cultures there) and our frequent TV watching and movie-going. We continue as a big, isolated nation, ignorant and unconcerned about what is really going on beyond our shores. Much of this is a result of our history, our great physical size and our pride, but neither can we deny our poor educational outcomes, and embarrassing lack of interest in foreign languages and intolerance of other cultures. This ignorance prevents our citizenry from establishing a meaningful "national yardstick" with which they could compare our nation with others. Most of our national leaders would discourage such kind of thinking. They would rather keep the vast majority of us ignorant.

Too often, I hear people, like a relative of mine---(name withheld to avoid embarrassment)---who shuns foreign excursions--his reason: "We are the greatest nation in the world. What do I gotta see, in France?"

The problem with America may be that too many of us "ain't seen Paree", rather than too few.

Which brings to mind an interesting piece entitled: "America's season of hollow boastfulness", by Edward Luce, which appeared in the Financial Times, (September 9, 2009). The author examines the tendency of our politicians (and unquestioning journalist corps) to be over-expansive or jingoistically boastful about America during this 2012 campaign.Politicians in the throes of a campaign seem to be obliged, according to Luce, to favor swagger, boast, and national-aggrandizement as a means of attempting to increase their popular vote---though they almost always avoid discussion of our real and pressing problems. According to him, this unpleasant trend is especially apparent during this 2012 campaign. Luce states: "Tucked into Mitt Romney’s recent acceptance speech was a line that captured the hubristic side to America’s 2012 campaign. Praising Neil Armstrong, Mr Romney said the astronaut personified the American character: “That unique blend of optimism, humility and the utter confidence that when the world needs someone to do the really big stuff, you need an American......He added the obligatory line – also common among Democrats – that the US is 'the greatest nation in the history of the world'".

Luce reminds us that "from the nation’s birth, America’s leaders have detected the hand of providence in its journey. But since the attacks of September 11, 2001, oratorical jingoism has become blunter and more widespread. Alexis de Tocqueveille said that Americans lived in “the perpetual utterance of self-applause. To one degree or another most nations now share that impulse. But America has entered a new season of hollow boastfulness."

Luce digs for examples of historic American braggadocio from as far back as President Lincoln, who, used the line ( “last best hope of earth"), Franklin Roosevelt (“nothing to fear but fear itself”), Ronald Reagan (“shining city on a hill”), and even Michelle Obama (“the greatest nation on earth”).

Luce claims that our modern election campaigns indulge in hollow boasts and "in national denial". He states, "Whether you call it a one-way conversation or a dialogue of the deaf, campaign 2012 is steeped in denial."The US has real problems and deficiencies but who will face them or begin to seek a solution if our leaders saturate us with, "hollow boastfulness" or engage in "perpetual utterances of self-applause"? Who will listen to those that suggest change if there is no belief that change is necessary.

But on the other hand, we don't have to seek too far to establish facts that will help clear the miasma created by the blow hard politicians, crowing over American greatness and exceptionalism and ignoring our problems which beg for solution.

In a study of modern economic theories I discovered that the model for the economic policy favored by Republican politicians and rightward leaning economists (the Austrian or Chicago School) is known as the the "American Model" and is different from that which is favored by German, French and other economists. How does it work? It doesn't work so good, in fact. It is the model used here in the last several decades and which ended us in the trash heap of the Great Recession. The American model is reported to "promote low wages and high inequality." Wait! That is not good. Nothing to boast about there.

But there is more. Economic studies show that the USA, due in large part to its Republican-style neoliberal polices; has low wages and high wage and wealth inequality. In the US, only 40% of our workers are adequately employed, ( and these data predate the current great recession) the other two thirds are either working for very low wages (30%) or are underemployed. That's nothing to be proud of.Several studies show that deliberate neoliberal polices (supported most vociferously by the GOP) encourage "anti-unionism", and "profiteering in the health industry". I can not write a glowing report to my London relatives about that. In comparison to other modern democracies , the US has "substantial levels of social exclusion" ( meaning not all social groups have access to the same level of education, opportunities of employment, housing and health care). We have higher levels of income inequality than most European nations ( differences in wealth and wages between the rich and poor are greater than other equally wealthy nations and that results in a restricted smaller middle class). Furthermore, regarding poverty--We have high rates of it on absolute terms (not relative to our population size). In education, we have poor and unequal educational outcomes (our kids go through our school, but find themselves un-prepared for employment or higher education). In health care we pay a lot more than other nations, but have poor health outcomes (we spend more on health care but are sicker longer and don't live as long as other equally advanced nations). As regards crime, we are king in that category! We have high rates of crime and staggering rates of incarceration (we jail more people than any other nation in the world). It's easy to dumped into a cell here in the US, but climbing up on the ladder of success is more difficult for us. We have lower levels of economic mobility (its harder for a plumber's kid here in the US to move up into an executive position in a corporation than in any other country in western Europe). So, I can't boast about any of that stuff to my French friends!

Studies of policies in vogue here (i.e. GOP style neoliberalism) with its vaunted "labor-market flexibility" (the term refers to a company's policies regarding hiring and firing employees, and the modern trend toward part-time or "flex jobs) show that such polices do not improve labor-market outcomes. In other words "It ain't good for business in the long run." These circumstances in the US give us no valid reason to swagger.

We got problems! And we got to stop this phony bragging. It only digs the hole deeper. In the end, objective analysis reveals, we are not so good at a lot of things, but it is very worrying to think that we might not be smart enough to know it.

Now that would be a problem!

Get the picture?

rjk

REVEALED: BUSH IGNORES MULTIPLE CIA WARNINGS FOR 9-11; REJECTS CIA INFO ON WMD, CREATES HIS OWN EVIDENCE TO GO TO WAR

In today's (September 10, 2012) NY Times, Kurt Eichenwald, drops a bomb on the ongoing attempts of George Bush, and Dick Cheney's to cleanse their records surrounding the 9-11-01 tragedy. Eichenwald, with his op-ed contribution: The Deafness Before the Storm , points out that President George Bush was very probably culpable for either ignoring a long string of urgent CIA warnings or simple not in charge of his office.

After the tragedy, Bush pushed the blame onto the CIA, charging that they did not provide him with sufficient-lead time or enough information. But Eichenwald's story bursts that bubble. New evidence reveals that the investigative and intelligence services were "banging the drums" from the early Spring of '01 indicating " we have an attack coming". But Bush did nothing. The infamous "last daily briefing book" issued on August 6, 2001, in which the title:" Bin Laden Determined to Strike in US" (could anything be more specific?) actually indicated an imminent attack. Bush and administration officials dismissed the briefing as "only an assessment of al Qaida's history and not a warning of an impending attack". It seems hard to swallow, but then our press also believed the nonsense they were offered on Iraq's WMD. Eichenwald gives them a pass on that and concludes that the Bush assessment may have had some validity---but if one only read the August 6th briefing--the last briefing. But when put in context with earlier briefing books the story is very different. The problem that Bush's team released only that last one--August 6, and no earlier ones made such an assessment impossible--until now.

Eichenwald's research indicates there were previous briefings that made the case for a more serious assessment of that last briefing book. Meaning that, looking at that last briefing book in context with the others give an entirely different perspective to how a reasonably alert, responsible, and concerned President would interpret these data. Bush was out "cutting brush in Texas," when he should have been paying attention to the nation's external threats. These revelations leads one to the conclusion that there was indeed some level of culpability in the Bush Administration and with Bush himself who ignored the advice of his own CIA concerning the threat of an impending attack. That attack killed three thousand civilians.

What is sad and ironic is that Bush ignored continued, valid and ultimately imminent CIA evidence presented to him prior to the 9-11 tragedy, when he should have paid attention to them. But later in his administration, in the period preceding the Iraq War, Bush and Cheney, again ignored their CIA advisers regarding the lack of evidence for WMD in Iraq and instead cherry-picked among information the CIA had rejected as invalid (some were statements from an informant known to the CIA as "Curveball") and data gathered by Cheney's accomplices in the Vice Presidential staff (convicted felon Scooter Libby among them). They even worked up information which other nation's had rejected as invalid. Bush and Cheney (with a complicitous Tony Blair) used this phoney data to gin up an invasion and a war that was tragic, costly, unwise and unwarranted. There were no WMD!

Thus the new information underscores the fact that Bush junior ignored valid threats which caused the deaths of more than three thousand American civilians on 9-11 then, manufactured reasons out of whole cloth for an invasion and war which caused the deaths of more than five thousand of our troops and hundreds of thousands of innocent Iraqis. This new reputation of Bush perhaps has us harken back to 37-41 BC and Roman Emperor Caligula who ranked as the worst Emperor of that former world empire. This new information will certainly make it difficult for the revisers of history (Ari Fleischer and Jeb Bush among them) who are actively attempting to wipe the slate clean for the culpable Bush and evil Cheny's reputations. Eichenwald's block buster article and his new book (500 days) will now make that objective very much more difficult.

In fact, the commendable efforts of the former Anglican Archbishop of South Africa Desmond TuTu to bring both George Bush and Tony Blair to trial at the Hague for their crimes against humanity in regard to their collusion during the events leading up to the Iraq War may be strengthened by these new revelations.

Get the picture?


rjk

Monday, September 10, 2012

THE DANGER OF PERPETUAL SELF APPLAUSE



The popular song of the WW I era, "How will you keep 'em down on the farm (after they've seen Paree)?" (by Lewis, Young and Donaldson, 1918) underscored the troubling question about the perceptions of returning doughboys and how they might change once they were exposed to the wider more sophisticated world in Europe. Perhaps Lewis and Young who wrote the lyrics were aware of our isolation, and insularism, and saw it as a potential problem as far back as the outbreak of WWI, nearly a hundred years ago. Today, that problem has not ameliorated much, even with all our scintillating technology, i-pads, i-pods and i-phones, pulsing internet, a decade of deploying hundreds of thousands of troops to the Middle East,(and still little change in interest in the languages and cultures there) and our frequent TV watching and movie-going. We continue as a big, isolated nation, ignorant and unconcerned about what is really going on beyond our shores. Much of this is a result of our history, our great physical size and our pride, but who can deny our poor educational outcomes, and embarrassing lack of interest in foreign languages and intolerance of other cultures. This ignorance prevents our citizenry from establishing a meaningful "national yardstick" with which they could compare our nation with others. Most of our national leaders would discourage such kind of thinking. They would rather keep the vast majority of us ignorant.

Too often, I hear people, like a relative of mine---(name withheld to avoid embarrassment)---who shuns foreign excursions--because, "We are the greatest nation in the world. What do I gotta see, in France?"

The problem with America may be that too many of us "ain't seen Paree!", rather than too few.

Which brings to mind an interesting piece entitled: "America's season of hollow boastfulness", by Edward Luce, in the Financial Times, (September 9, 2009) in which the author examines the tendency of our politicians (and unquestioning journalist corps) to be over-expansive and boastful about America during this 2012 campaign.

Politicians in the throes of a campaign seem to be obliged, according to Luce, to use favor swagger, boast, and national-aggrandizement as a means of attempting to boost their popular vote. Though they almost always avoid discussion of our real and pressing problems. According to him, this unpleasant trend is especially apparent during this 2012 campaign. Luce states: "Tucked into Mitt Romney’s recent acceptance speech was a line that captured the hubristic side to America’s 2012 campaign. Praising Neil Armstrong, Mr Romney said the astronaut personified the American character: “That unique blend of optimism, humility and the utter confidence that when the world needs someone to do the really big stuff, you need an American......He added the obligatory line – also common among Democrats – that the US is 'the greatest nation in the history of the world'".

Luce reminds us that "from the nation’s birth, America’s leaders have detected the hand of providence in its journey. But since the attacks of September 11, 2001, oratorical jingoism has become blunter and more widespread. Alexis de Tocqueveille said that Americans lived in “the perpetual utterance of self-applause. To one degree or another most nations now share that impulse. But America has entered a new season of hollow boastfulness." Luce digs for examples of historic American braggadocio from as far back as President Lincoln, who, used the line ( “last best hope of earth"), Franklin Roosevelt (“nothing to fear but fear itself”), Ronald Reagan (“shining city on a hill”), and even Michelle Obama (“the greatest nation on earth”).

Luce claims that our modern election campaigns indulge in hollow boasts and "in national denial". He states, "Whether you call it a one-way conversation or a dialogue of the deaf, campaign 2012 is steeped in denial."

The US has real problems and deficiencies but who will face them or begin to seek a solution if our leaders saturate us with, "hollow boastfulness" or engage in "perpetual utterances of self-applause"? Who will listen to those that suggest change if there is no belief that change is necessary.

But on the other hand, we don't have to seek too far to establish baseline data that will help clear the miasma created by the blow hard politicians, crowing over American greatness and exceptionalism and ignoring our problems which beg for solution.

In a study of modern economic theories I discovered that the model for the economic policy favored by Republican politicians and rightward leaning economists (the Austrian or Chicago School) is known as the the "American Model" and is different from that which is favored by German, French and other economists. How does it work? It doesn't work so good, in fact. It is the model used here in the last several decades and which ended us in the trash heap of the Great Recession. The American model is reported to "promote low wages and high inequality." Wait! That is not good. Nothing to boast about there. But there is more.

Economic studies show that the USA, due in large part to its Republican-style neoliberal polices; has low wages and high wage and wealth inequality. In the US, only 40% of our workers are adequately employed, ( and these data predate the current great recession) the other two thirds are either working for very low wages (30%) or are underemployed. That's nothing to be proud of.

Several studies show that deliberate neoliberal polices (supported most vociferously by the GOP) encourage "anti-unionism", and "profiteering in the health industry". I can not write a glowing report to my London relatives about that.

In comparison to other modern democracies , the US has "substantial levels of social exclusion" ( meaning not all social groups have access to the same level of education, opportunities of employment, housing and health care). We have higher levels of income inequality than most European nations ( differences in wealth and wages between the rich and poor are greater than other equally wealthy nations and that results in a restricted smaller middle class). Furthermore, regarding poverty--We have high rates of it on absolute terms (not relative to our population size). In education, we have poor and unequal educational outcomes (our kids go through our school, but find themselves un-prepared for employment or higher education). In health care we pay a lot but have poor health outcomes (we spend more on health care but are sicker longer and don't live as long as other equally advanced nations). As regards crime, we are king in that category! We have high rates of crime and staggering rates of incarceration (we jail more people than any other nation in the world). But climbing up on the ladder of success is more difficult for us. We have lower levels of economic mobility (its harder for a plumber's kid here in the US to move up into an executive position in a corporation than in any other country in western Europe). I can't boast about any of that stuff to my French friends!

Studies of policies in vogue here (i.e. GOP style neoliberalism) with its vaunted "labor-market flexibility" (the term refers to a company's policies regarding hiring and firing employees, and the modern trend toward part-time or "flex jobs) show that such polices do not improve labor-market outcomes. In other words "It ain't good for business in the long run." These also give us no valid reason to swagger.

We got problems! And we got to stop this phony bragging. It only digs the hole deeper. Objective analysis reveals, not only are we not so good at a lot of things, but it is worrying to think that we might not be smart enough to know it. Now that would be a problem

Get the picture?

rjk



Friday, September 7, 2012

SIMPLER TIMES: THE LOST ART OF BAIT FISHING



THE LOST ART OF BAIT FISHING



My first experience fishing, was as a ten year old on an outing with my elderly grandfather, to a small fresh-water pond, we fished with live, wriggly bait. In those days, fishing satisfied several objectives, it was a happy diversion on a hot summer day, it was relaxing, and  probably the most important reason was that the catch provided supper, or at least a welcome addition to supper.  Grandpa loved to eat fish and I think he would never have thought of bothering about it, if he could not come home with a nice stringer of pan fish.



One summer morning, grandpa, woke me early and motioned me to follow him.  Outside, I trailed him under the grape arbor where hanging clumps of still-green Concord grapes warmed in the morning sun.  We skirted the chicken coops and the rabbit hutches and finally stopped at the old wood shed on the far side of the farm.  Grandpa removed the big, brass Master-lock which he hardly ever snapped shut, it always just hung there unlocked. He hooked it on the door handle. He raised the rusty hasp and pulled.   The door swung open on groaning hinges, letting  the morning sun stream into the dusty interior,  a place I always longed to explore on my own, but was not allowed.

The old wood shed, never painted, and raised only on four locust posts was where grandpa stored all manner of interesting things----particularly exciting for a ten year-old boy.  Hanging on the wall across from the door was a rusty leg-hold fox trap (but grandpa never set one).  Near-by was a wire crab trap, and a broken minnow screen.  The big rolled up beach seine, rested against the wall, next  grandpa's ancient, single-shot Steven's .22 caliber rifle. I never saw him use that gun.  He hated to kill anything.  What always caught my eye was  an elk-horn-handled sheath knife, and leather sheath. But there were clam rakes, eel spears and forks, a bucket of well used hand tools and  jars and tin cans of rusty, salvaged nails, screws and bolts.  Many of which I was well acquainted with, since one of my jobs was to straighten nails, by rolling and pounding the bends out of them, on a big block of oak  with my own small hammer.  The shed was a testament to the fact that Grandpa never threw anything away. Discarded pieces of lumber, from the dilapidated back porch, were saved for firewood.  But prior to being  cut up into fire wood, all the old nails and other hardware had to be removed first.  Grandpa would pry the nails out, and I would hammer them straight, then drop them into the appropriate Mason jar or tin can. Grandpa saved, string wire, aluminum foil, paper, and just about anything you could not burn for fuel.  Shelves held jars and cans of salvaged, wood screws, carriage nuts and bolts  of all sizes, sheet metal screws. On the floor were coils of twisted hemp-rope, rolls of old wire, bits and pieces of copper, galvanized sheet metal.  Grandpa, recycled everything on his small three-acre chicken farm.  To me, the shed was a special place where we worked together at tasks like saving things, and creating new things out of old, that seemed so necessary, and so useful.

On this morning, Grandpa, shuffled across the gritty, dusty, tongue and groove floor toward the back of the structure and disappeared into the shadows where a tangle of slim, limber bamboo poles rested against the wall. He rustled among them, choosing two that for some reason, satisfied his needs. Carrying these under his arm, he moved to the shelf near the door, where from a small jelly jar which held a tangle of small, wire fishing hooks. He dislodged  three Eagle Claw hooks and carefully stuck them into a wine bottle cork he took from another jar.  He plucked a roll of Cuttyhunk, twisted linen fish-line from the shelf.  And that was it. 

Grandpa stuck the cork with the hooks into the small "bib" pocket on the top flap  of his Sweet-Orr overalls and with the two poles over our shoulders we walked down the gravelly drive together.

We didn't have any shiny moving lures, plastic worms, reels, creels, bait buckets, no waders, no landing nets, or even any special clothing...only a couple of coils of braided line, a few hooks and two limber bamboo poles.

We walked down the sandy roads toward the Smith Farm on St Johnland River Road.  About a mile away from the house, a bubbling artesian well--just a four inch diameter pipe stuck in the ground--poured water out of the ground and into a little stream. The stream bubbled and gurgled its way from the roadside into a five-acre pond hidden in the woods.  A little foot-trail led through the pitch pine, scrub oak, willow and low brush to a little clearing where long ago someone had rolled up a big pine log to act as a seat at a favorite fishing place. The pond, ringed by thick brush and cattails sparkled in the morning sun. 

Grandpa laid the two poles down across the log and sat down with a heavy humpff, like the walk to this place was a bit too long for a sixty-eight year old man. He tied the end of a hank of line to each of the bamboo pole tips. Removing the wine cork with the hooks on them out of the top pocket of his overalls. He tied one small hook to the end of each line. Each hook ended up at the end of the line about even with the butt of each pole. That's all the hardware we had.

"Robbie, now let's find us some bait."

That day, after a rainy night, for a first try, we pulled some clumps of grass from near the base of the log and searched the roots base for earthworms.  We found three big ones and dumped them into a small tin can with a bit of grass and soil to keep them moist. 

"When do we start to fish?" I asked, eager to begin.

"Let's gather some other baits," said grandpa, "and perhaps see how well each one works."  

Leaving the poles, we walked back along the path, carrying only our small tin bait can.  On our way, grandpa trapped a bumblebee under his big red bandana, plucking it from the top of a Queen Anne's Lace flower. As it buzzed angrily he carefully, pressed the trapped bee between his big calloused fingers and placed the now silent insect in our worm can.  From a clump of goldenrod he found some plants with enlarged galls on their stems. He pointed out to me that the galls were complete with no exit holes so the small white wiggly grub was still at home.  He pulled out his rosewood-handled, Barlow pocket knife and opening the big dark-stained blade, sliced two of the biggest galls from the stems. These he stuffed into our tin can worm container. 

Back at the log, we prepared to bait our hooks. Grandpa took the wine cork and cut it neatly into two equal rounds. He cut side of each round part way through, so that the braided line, could be slipped through the cork slice, a little wrap of fish line around each cork bobber kept the line in place.  Each cork was set on the line about a foot and a half above the hook.  

Grandpa's big rough hands then turned to our baits. One hook he baited with the now still bumblebee. He pushed the hook through the thick thorax so that the bee hung upright as if it was flying. 

"That's yours Robbie," he said, swinging the line out with its baited hook, so it plopped into the water about ten to fifteen feet out from the shore. "You hold that," he said, as he reached into the can for one of the galls.

I soon was mesmerized by watching the little half-cork floating in the center of a little ring of ripples in the water. That day I learned how to strike the hook when that cork jiggled. A shoal of small yellow perch, each about six or eight inches long and would hit the bait with a rush and take the cork bobber down below the surface dragging the line down and away.  I caught two fish on the bumblebee and then I turned to the worms.  Grandpa showed me how to drape them onto the hook so they would "look natural" in the water.   That day, in a short time, we caught a nice string of fish

It was simple and joyful to raise the tip of the long pole and hook the struggling fish. A simple turn of the body brought the flapping, flopping, vertically black-stripped fish to the grass patch, where grandpa released it from the hook.  

Before we had our first fish he had ready in his pocket a two yard length of linen line with each end tied to the center of a two-inch long sharpened stake.  He had cut the stakes from a dry willow branch. One of the small sharpened stakes he slipped through the fish's gaping mouth, past the red gills and out through the hard gill cover of each fish. Then he pushed the other stake into the soft earth close to the water's rippling edge. To keep the fish fresh, he tossed the still flapping perch back into the shallow water where it tugged the line taught, trying to escape into deep water. 

That morning, we caught a dozen small perch and happily carried the dripping still flapping fish home to be breaded and fried to crisp, moist perfection in grandma's big iron frypan.

The episode never left my consciousness. I was as well hooked (on fishing), after that day, as all those active tugging perch---for the rest of my life. As I write this, I can still see, the pond, feel the bump of the fish on my line, see their little torpedo-shaped, flapping bodies, fifty years later. And I can still remember the taste the fresh moist flesh of the fine little fish that made our supper that night.  

On other days, we fished the Spring Pond with grubs from the goldenrod galls. We caught white cabbage butterflies with small nets and sometimes even big moths. These were impaled a tiny wire hook with no bobber and floated on the water's surface to catch big Red Breast Sunnies. On other occasions we collected crickets, which we caught in little tin-can-traps placed under the arbor at night and baited with bread crumbs.  We collected "night crawlers" or earth worms by laying an old rug out on the compost heap near the garden patch, soaking it down with a bucket of water in the evening, and on the next morning lifting it up to find it active with moist, shining, iridescent earth worms. Sometimes running out of bait, we might turn over the old log right at the fishing spot on Spring Lake to look for critters under there. We often found black ground beetles and white grubs of various other insects in the rotted wood.

Smith's Spring Pond is still there, though a bit more weedy in the middle, (and now I can not vouch for the purity of the water) and though the old pipe has rusted away, ground water still seeps out of the same old wet spot to feed a stream of clear cold water into the pond.  I haven't fished there in a long time, but I have seen some others fishing there...though with a lot more equipment than grandpa and I had, and of course no wriggly, natural baits that a kid could learn so much from. 

Get the picture?             

rjk

Thursday, September 6, 2012

THE SOCIAL CONTRACT AND "YOU DIDN'T BUILD THAT"



“I swear by my life and my love of it that I will never live for the sake of another man, nor ask another man to live for mine.”― Ayn Rand, Atlas Shrugged 1957

So states John Galt in Ayan Rand's "Atlas Shrugged", a piece of fiction of the last century which young Congressman Paul Ryan, now the Republican choice for VP, claims as his personal philosophy and even suggests we are now living in a Ayn Rand world! Rand (and her young devotee, Paul Ryan) favor a world where the rugged individual, one of the "special people" who left to his (or her) own devices--unencumbered by government interference, achieves greatness, and wealth. Since they operate on their own, with no eoutside help in this fictional Randian world, they and only they deserve the fruits of their labors. Greed is good, and---no sharing allowed! I suggest here that Ryan go to Yemen a place where there is little government and infrastructure to interfere with his efforts at greatness and to test out Ayn Rand's theories.

Rand's fiction, her atheism, and her philosophy, in her day, were on the far fringe of acceptance--where they remain today. The underlying reason for this is that her premises call into question and are at such varience with so much of Christian teaching and academic research regarding how we interact with our neighbors and even what "society" is. The basic tenets shaping our thinking and those of the Founding Fathers were derived from the works of Hobbs and Rousseau (Leviathan and Social Contract) whose concepts of the "social compact" is that man chooses for his or her own good to join the state and surrender some of their freedoms for mutual benefit. Thus it smacks of injustice and unfairness, if one at first accepts the terms of societie's membership and then, having profited, turns around and rejects the need to pay up one's fair share for the benefits one made use of.

We all can accept that there are some of us who work harder than others---and have prospered. There are others in our great nation who have not. Either they are not wise enough, are ill, lame, or not so capable as others, either mentally or physically. Yes some may even be malingerers. Every society has a few. Looking at populations as a scientist might, we learn that the traits which lead to success can be plotted on a bell curve graph...ambition, ability, wits, business sense, etcetera, etcetera. Those traits are variables which are largely responsible for where a person might show up in the "success" bell curve. Those that do prosper, found in the middle and the far tail-end of the curve, should be fairly rewarded for their efforts. But even of this select group, none of us live in a vacuum, or on a desert island. We are part of a society, a network of interacting and interconnected individuals, and profit or suffer by the actions, economic decisions and behaviors or our co-citzens.

The physician who trains for eight or more post-baccalaureate years (and then more years to gain a speciality) may truly believe that he or she has done it all by him or herself. The long hours of study, the financial sacrifice--the still-unsatisfied loans are seared into that person's conciousness. They deserve enormous credit for their hard work, skill, ability, and sacrifice. . But the economist, or sociologist (or even wise politician) must look at their efforts and successes with the knowledge that their achievement was also dependent upon many other elements which they gained with their entry into society: national financial status, family support, the sacrifices of their wives or husbands, the ccommunity from which they came, the infrastructure which permitted them to prepare for their work, the librarians, the teachers, and the police who kept their neighborhood safe, the engineers who routed their city electrical supply, all the institutions and infrastructure which were there for them to make their lives sustainable and their sucess possible. These were not free. Someone paid for them. They as we do, all live within a great skein of interactions that make their success possible. Yes, you didn't build that---alone. Not one successful businessman, great scientist, or artist I know rose up, book or invention in hand from a desert island. We are a sociali animal, and our survival and advancement depends on interactions with others.

President Obama intimated just that when campaigning in Virginia, on July 15, 2012, when he stated in part that "If you have a business, you didn't built that" The Republicans use of Obama’s simple re-statement of our social contract as a bludgeon, to suggest that he is not sensitive to business needs and his remarks demeaned their efforts is not fair or valid. What he was stating is a fact, a restatment of something we all intuitively accept. We are all interconnected, we are part of a great nation, not some work of fiction, living out an isolated, individual, greedy life in an imaginary place. As members of a society, we have a responsibility to our community, our nation and to the citizenry who populate that entity.

Mitt Romney, did not make his $20 or $30 billion dollar fortune in the wastelands of the Sahara. He made it here in the US, taking advantage of every opportunity. To start up Bain Capital he sought investment money from family and friends, and even from shady El Salvador capitalists (with ties to death squads operating in that country). He used US government supported loans. He took full advantage of existing businesses and banks, and the infrastructure of this nation and the largess of our government’s policies to support entrepreneurship. He in particular, should be wary of bragging that ”I made it on my own". Here is a man who literally was born with a silver spoon in his mouth. He came from a wealthy, privileged, politically and financially connected background. Doors were opened (wide) for him, entree into the best clubs, society, and with this came the opportunity to rub shoulders with the rich and well-heeled. People he used to support his endeavors. He used all those valuable assets to make his own way. But he did use them. How can he claim he built ”it” on his own? He was successful and he deserves credit for his success...but let's not fool ourselves into thinking that he did it all by himself.

This discussion always brings to my mind the hazy dust clouded image of the Republic of Yemen. With that thought comes the corollary idea: that Yemen is just the place where Paul Ryan and Mitt Romney should go to test out their abilities to really build a Ayn Rand style empire on their own--fully free of government services and intervention, they so despise here.

Yemen is an Arabic-speaking, hot, dusty, parliamentary republic with an area of about the size of Spain, located on the desertified southwestern tip of the Arabian peninsula, across the Red Sea from the Horn of Africa. It is one of the poorest and least developed nations in the world. It’s population of about 25 million are generally tall and skinny, underfed (much of Yemeni food is UN donated) and always thirsty. Each Yemeni must survive for a whole year on the volume of water most of the rest of the world uses in only one month (or what Americans use in only two weeks.). It’s capital city, Sana'a, just recently ran out of potable water. Their infrastructure is non-existent. There are few major roads, no rail system, and no network of electrical supply. There is no regional electrical grid in the nation. In Sana’a, electricity is individually generated by each house or business, which can afford it, using oil-fired generators. Consequently, in Yemen electricity costs 12 times what it would cost in the US. Think of the din in Sana'a with every business running its own noisy, gas-belching generator on its sidewalk or roof top. Think of the choking, gasping levels of air pollution. There is little postal service, and no established medical care. There is little in the way of policing. Only armed tribal bands to intervene were some other nation to invade or hungry Yemenis to rise up in protest. In Yemen, your well-being and survival are pretty much on your own shoulders.

Yemen would be an ideal place for Paul Ryan to experiment with his fictional Randian world view. He might test out how well a staunch, rugged, individualist such as Paul Ryan, or Mitt Romney, would mange in their attempts at building their empires all on their own in a place with no infrastructure. In Yemen they could be completly free of any societal restraints and pay-backs, they could greedily hoard all of their profits. From my perspective they are heartily encouraged to go there and prove out their world view.

Think of it...Romney in his starched white shirt in the dusty, streets of Sana'a in Yemen!

Get the picture?

rjk

Wednesday, September 5, 2012

EXTREME INDIVIDUALISM OR ROMNEY AND RYAN IN YEMEN

THE TRUTH ABOUT "YOU DIDN'T BUILD THAT"

“I swear by my life and my love of it that I will never live for the sake of another man, nor ask another man to live for mine.”
― Ayn Rand, Atlas Shrugged

I don't care what President Obama said or didn't say on the campaign trail regarding building or not building a business. We all can accept that there are some of us who work hard and prosper and there are others in our great nation who do not. Either they are not wise enough, are ill, lame, or not so capable as others, either mentally or physically. Yes some may be malingerers. Every society has them. Looking at every population as a scientist might, we learn that all these traits can be plotted on a bell curve graph...ambition ability, wits, business sense, etcetera, etcetera. Those traits are variables which are largely responsible for where a person might show up in the great "success bell curve". Those that do prosper, found in the middle of the curve and the far tail-end, should be rewarded for their efforts.

But none of us live in a vacuum, or on a desert island. We are part of a society, a network of interacting and interconnected individuals, their actions, economic decisions and behaviors. The physician who trains for eight or more post-baccalaureate years (and then more years to gain a speciality) may believe that he or she has done it all by him or herself. He or she can only remember the long hours of study, the financial sacrifice--the still unsatisfied loans. They deserve enormous credit for their hard work, skill, ability, and sacrifice. We can understand and forgive any bias they demonstrate. But an economist, or sociologist (or wise politician) must look at the efforts and successes of these people and understand that their achievement was dependent upon many other factors as well: financial status, family support, the sacrifices of their wives or husbands, the society from which they came, the infrastructure which permitted them to prepare for their work, the librarians, the teachers, and the police who kept their neighborhood safe, the engineers who routed their city electrical supply, all the institutions and infrastructure which were there for them to make their lives sustainable and their sucess possible. The great skein of interactions that made their success possible. None of us live alone on a desert island. We are a socialized animal, and our survival and advancement depends on interactions with others.

The Republicans use of Obama’s statement as a bludgeon, to suggest that he is demeaning their efforts is not fair or valid. What he was stating is a fact...we are all interconnected, we are part of a great nation, not some fictional Randian character, in a John Galt novel, living out isolated, individual greedy lives in an imaginary place. As members of a society, we have a responsibility to our nation and to the citizenry who populate that entity.

Mitt Romney, did not make his $20 or $30 billion dollar fortune in the wastelands of the Sahara. He made it here in the US. To start up Bain Capital he used start-up money from family and friends, and even from shady capitalists from El Salvador. He used government supported loans. He took full advantage of existing businesses and banks, and the infrastructure of this nation and the largess of our government’s policies to support entrepreneurship. He in particular should be wary of using the ”I made it on my own" bludgeon. He came from a wealthy, privileged, politically and financially connected background. Doors were opened (wide) for him, entree into the best clubs, society, and ability to rub shoulders with the rich and well-heeled were all there for his taking. He used those assets to make his own way. But he did use them. How can he claim he built ”it” on his own? He was successful and he deserves credit for his success...but let's not fool ourselves into thinking that he did it all by himself.

This discussion always brings to my mind the image of the Republic of Yemen. Yemen is an Arabic-speaking, hot, dusty, parliamentary republic with an area of about the size of Spain, located on the desertified southwestern tip of the Arabian peninsula, across the Red Sea from the Horn of Africa. It is one of the poorest and least developed nations in the world. It’s population of about 25 million are generally, skinny, underfed (much of its food is UN donated) and thirsty. Each Yemeni must survive for a whole year on the amount of water most of the rest of the world uses in one month. It’s capital city recently completely ran out of potable water. The infrastructure is non-existent. There are few major roads, no rail system, and no network of electrical supply. Electricity in Sana’a, the capital city, is individually produced by oil fired generators. Thus, in Yemen electricity costs 12 times (!)what it would cost in the US. Think of the din in Sana'a with every business running its own noisy, gas-belching generator on its sidewalk or roof top. Think of the choking, gasping levels of air pollution. There is little postal service, and no established medical care. There is little in the way of policing. Only armed tribal bands to intervene were some other nation to invade. In Yemen you are pretty much on your own--for survival. Yemen would be a wonderful place to test out how well a ”staunch” Ayn Rand-style individualist such as Paul Ryan, or Mitt Romney, would do building their empires all on their own then greedily hoarding all of their profits. They are welcome to go there and try.

Think of it...Romney in Yemen!

Get the picture?


rjk

THe truth about ”you didn't build that, staunch individualists Ryan and Romney are invited to Yemen where they can act out a John Gault role.

Monday, September 3, 2012

"THE MAN WHO LIES TO THE WORLD IS THE WORLD'S SLAVE" --Ayn Rand 1957

“People think that a liar gains a victory over his victim. What I’ve learned is that a lie is an act of self-abdication, because one surrenders one’s reality to the person to whom one lies, making that person one’s master, condemning oneself from then on to faking the sort of reality that person’s view requires to be faked…The man who lies to the world, is the world’s slave from then on…There are no white lies, there is only the blackest of destruction, and a white lie is the blackest of all.”
― Ayn Rand, "Atlas Shrugged".


RYAN A SOCIOPATHIC LIAR?

Paul Ryan, the Republican choice for VP this election cycle, comes from a small town in southeastern Wisconsin, where I suspect, as a kid, he never had his mouth washed out with brown soap for lying--as I did. That unpleasant experience, the acrid taste, the constant need to salivate to clear the awful flavor was a regular and pointed reminder for me to watch more carefully how I treated the truth. I can't say I never lied again, but I sure did try hard to break that habit of cutting a path too far away from the truth. And that's what it is-- a bad habit. The Republican VP candidate, Paul Ryan has that habit in a bad way.

I can only suspect that like other habits, Paul's lying came on him slowly, like other forms of addiction. I recall my first puff of experimental tobacco smoke, it gags you, and makes your eyes tear. But the other twelve year-old kids with me didn't notice my watery eyes, and coughing behind my hand, they only saw the blue smoke streaming out of my burning nostrils. As they watched the smoke coiling gracefully above my head, I focused on them. I could see in their eyes a grudging, new-found respect and admiration for a small, skinny, inconsequential sixth grader. That bit of acceptance and admiration made my gagging and eye tearing worth while. That was the gratification,(at first) for my unwise smoking experiment. It worked to impress my peers.

So it was with Ryan. When he first ran for public office as a gangling, unmarried, twenty-something-stripling, he (correctly) felt he was too young, unprepared and insecure to compete. To win, he concluded he must delude and impress the voters. One method he is reported to have used on his campaign trips was to have his sister and her infant accompany him on his campaign stops. He purposely created the erroneous impression that the lovely young woman and her child were his young wife and baby. It worked. He manipulated the voters into thinking he was a mature, stable man with a wife and a growing family. His other ploy was to set up campaign photo-ops at construction sites where he would wear a bright yellow safety "hard hat". He made sure he was photographed in front of the construction machinery to create the false impression that he worked there. He could set that up easily, since his paternal family owned Ryan Construction Central a large construction company. Once again his deception worked! He was able to create the erroneous impression that he was an engineer or construction manager--not a college kid, a political wonk, with an undergraduate degree in politics and economics on which the ink was still wet. He became hooked, addicted to creating false impressions which he pushed on the unsuspecting public. Such behavior fits the definition of a sociopathic liar.

A sociopath is typically defined as someone who lies incessantly to get their way and does so with little concern for others. A sociopath is often goal-oriented (i.e., lying is focused - it is done to get one's way). Sociopaths have little regard or respect for the rights and feelings of others. Sociopaths are often charming and charismatic, but they use their talented social skills in manipulative and self-centered ways.

(See Truth about deception: http://www.truthaboutdeception.com/lying-and-deception/confronting-a-partner/compulsive-lying/types-of-liars.html)

Once in office, Ryan's technique worked particularly well in his somewhat backwater, insular, First Congressional district. The First CD is situated in the southeastern corner of Wisconsin stretching from Lake Michigan's shore into the hinterlands of the state and the Route 39 corridor. This portion of Wisconsin has few large cities, scanty big media or newspaper outlets, or influential universities. It is a very "middle of the country" place, where about 80% of the population is urban and nearly ninety percent of the citizenry work either at white-collar (@60%) or blue collar (@30) jobs. It is about 90% white, and about average in median income. Voters trend toward the Republican party. The unsophisticated middle and working class population perhaps became a form of social "tabula rasa", upon which a sociopath could foist all sorts of miss-truths and obfuscations with little chance of someone powerful or sophisticated enough rising up and questioning the veracity of a Congressman's statements--even if that Congressman was just a beardless kid.

Ryan is smart, ambitious, unscrupulous and charming. He used all his wiles to become a master at creating self-aggrandizing and untrue impressions, obfuscations, deceptions, distortions, and-- while smiling charmingly--mouth perfidious statements, mendacious utterances, untruths, half-truths, plain lies and big whoppers. His successes with a largely unsophisticated, believable, simple and decent citizenry, who trusted him, only reinforced his tendency to continue to use these unsavory methods. In a way, his First CD supporters facilitated his mendacious habit.

But since his VP nomination, he has moved onto a larger more sophisticated stage. The nation's and the world's press now parse his every word--and unfortunately for him--his past utterances too. His bad habits and his lies are now exposed on a national stage in an embarrassing and dibilitating display.

Paul Ryan is a self-professed advocate and avid promoter of the works of Ayn Rand, the Russian emigre, angry refugee from the 1917 Communist Revolution, fiction author, and self-professed economist and philosopher. Congressman Ryan who famously claimed that Ayn Rand was the "single most influential person" in his life. He was the Congressman who attended and spoke at Ayn Rand conferences, and insisted that his Congressional staff read "Atlas Shrugged" and other Rand works, and even gave these books to his friends and staffers as Christmas gifts. Such a devotee should have at some point come across a famous quote on lying (see above under header) taken from Rand's fiction, "Atlas Shrugged". (But perhaps, then he just lied about that too.)

The key sentence that should have been underlined in Ryan's personal copy is this: "The man who lies to the world, is the world's slave from then on."

Rand's words were prophetic, for Ryan has become "the slave of his own lies". His mendacious behavior became self-reinforcing and addictive, simply because his untruths worked! This behavior brought him immediate self-gratification, re-election several times over, and political success.

But how much of a "slave" he has become to his lies became apparent to us all just recently when he was interviewed on a right-wing radio talk show. The interviewer brought up Ryan's well publicized athletic prowess. During the ensuing conversation, Ryan mentioned that he continues to run "ten miles" at a clip. The interviewer picked up on that and asked if he had run a marathon. Ryan responded that he had, and his answer implied that he had run several marathons. The logical next question from the interviewer was: "What was your best time?". Ryan, without hesitation answered, "Under three hours," and added, more precisely, "two hours, fifty something." The response of the interviewer was "Wow!"

He understood how exceptional that was (or what a whopper it was). So let's give Ryan the benefit of the doubt and let him claim a two-hour, fifty-nine minute marathon. That would mean that Ryan would have had to have been averaging better than a seven minute (6.9 min) mile for each of the twenty six plus miles of that marathon. Only professional super-athletes can sustain such speeds. For example, the top-ten world-marathon times range from two hours and three minutes to two hours and four minutes--all run by men from Kenya. "Two hours fifty something"--would be something indeed. Hearing this conversation on the radio, some Runner's World journalists tried to research Ryan's actual times. They found only one marathon Ryan had run...twenty years ago. His actual time was "four hours and four minutes". This was a bald-faced lie and not accidental. How could one forget such a thing? A whole hour slogging along in the last part of a marathon run is painful enough to be seared into one's memory. It is not a thing that one would likely forget. Furthernore, four hours was a good time! Why didn't he simply tell the truth?

The reason: he is an habitual liar. One must conclude that such behavior brings into question his suitability for high office. The man, a heart beat away from the Presidency, must be trusted and believed.

Other Paul Ryan lies with a similar modus operandi as in his initial foray into politics as a young man (with a phony hard hat and sister's baby in tow) follow .

  • "Accused President Obama’s health care law of funneling money away from Medicare “at the expense of the elderly.” In fact, Medicare’s chief actuary says the law “substantially improves” the system’s finances, and Ryan himself has embraced the same savings.
  • Accused Obama of doing “exactly nothing” about recommendations of a bipartisan deficit commission — which Ryan himself helped scuttle.
  • Claimed the American people were “cut out” of stimulus spending. Actually, more than a quarter of all stimulus dollars went for tax relief for workers.
  • Faulted Obama for failing to deliver a 2008 campaign promise to keep a Wisconsin plant open. It closed less than a month before Obama took office.
  • Blamed Obama for the loss of a AAA credit rating for the U.S. Actually, Standard & Poor’s blamed the downgrade on the uncompromising stands of both Republicans and Democrats."
(From Factcheck.org, Aug 20, 2012)

Ryan lies about social security, about medicare, about women's health care issues.
And the band plays on, with Paul Ryan writing and rewriting the fictional lyrics to achieve his own personal advancement. Everytime he opens his moouth remember his personal history and that he never had his mouth washed out with brown soap.


He is a sociopathic liar.

Get the picture?

rjk